The Limits of Motherhood -- and the Constitution
Cody Miyler is a fellow with an abundance of gall. After being dismissed as police chief of East Galesburg, Ill., Miyler sued the town of 900, claiming a violation of his constitutional due process rights. Apparently East Galesburg has an ordinance decreeing that the town "president" must sign off on police chief firings, and Miyler claimed that the then-president - who happened to be his mother - hadn't given her consent.
But gall only gets you so far with the law (just ask OJ Simpson). And so it was that the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals last week decided to end Miyler's curiously-long quest for satisfaction from the town he briefly served.
The court declared in a five-page opinion that there was no "due process" right to the job and that, even if there were, it would not generate a "property interest" sufficient to trigger constitutional protection.
Miyler served as East Galesburg police chief, at a salary of $9 a day, for only two plus years. The village board of trustees voted to remove him in 2003 after becoming, in the court's words, "troubled by various allegations of misconduct by Miyler, such as his providing beer to some underage boys, using a local brickyard for a firing range, and being ticketed for riding a motorcycle without a valid license, a 'violation' to which he entered a guilty plea."
Yet it took nearly five years of legal wrangling to get to this point.
Now, Miyler could try to get a hearing before the full 7th Circuit or the Supreme Court. But thankfully his chance of success is slim. You can usually tell how hard an appellate ruling is by the length of time between oral argument and the opinion. Here, oral argument took place Dec. 2, with the decision coming Jan. 9. Five weeks. A blink of an eye in the legal system. That tells you how lopsided the case really was.
It's a shame that the federal courts spend any time on these sorts of silly loser cases. But it's something to keep in mind when federal judges -- led by Chief Justice John Roberts -- beg politicians for more judges and more money.
Please email us to report offensive comments.
Posted by: Steagall | January 15, 2008 11:19 AM
Posted by: DC | January 15, 2008 11:27 AM
Posted by: | January 18, 2008 01:42 AM
Posted by: Bipin Adhikari | January 18, 2008 01:43 AM