Network News

X My Profile
View More Activity
Post Rock Archive  |  About the Bloggers  |  E-mail: Click Track  |  On Twitter: Click Track  |  RSS Feeds RSS

Taking sides... Choose your own Coachella adventure

Thom Yorke Jay-ZJay-Z and Thom Yorke can play at your version of Coachella - but it will cost you.

In an effort to turn everything in life into some kind of draft and/or fantasy sport, Click Track has developed a Coachella salary cap game. This allows us to sift through nearly 100 acts playing at April's massive music festival in the California desert and curate our own mini-fest. But it's not as easy as simply putting your 10 favorite bands on the bill. You must work within a budget.

The rules: You get $500,000 to spend. Each band is assigned a value based on poster placement. (Top line = $200k, 2nd line = $100k, 3rd/4th line = $60k, 5th/6th line = $40k, others = $20k; an easier to read breakdown is available after the jump.) You must pick at least 7 bands. You may pick no more than 10 bands. This means you can't just pick Jay-Z, Gorillaz, Thom Yorke???? and call it a day.

After the jump we reveal our lineups, our reasoning and our toughest omissions. Please play along and share your own creations -- just make sure to stick to the rules. (Note: We know that these are not the actual dollar amounts these acts are getting paid; Chris especially knows this. It just made it easier for this exercise.)

Chris Richards:

Sly and the Family Stone ($60k + $40k bonus), Faith No More ($100k), Spoon ($60k), Phoenix ($60k), Dirty Projectors ($60k), Calle 13 ($40k), Wale ($20k), Aeroplane ($20k), Beach House ($20k), Shooter Jennings ($20k)

Would you depend on this man to headline your festival? (AP Photo/Mark J. Terrill)

Sly Stone gets the headlining slot at my Coachella -- and to prevent him from delivering a disastrous set, he'll be paid a $40,000 bonus the moment he steps off stage for turning the party out. Faith No More will be grossly overpaid for their warm-up slot, but if we're all going to spend the day fighting heat exhaustion, we deserve to hear "Epic" at sundown.

Spoon and Phoenix will perform back-to-back sets just to confirm that they aren't the same band. If Wale has UCB backing him, he's a steal. But if the band stays home, he has to freestyle a cameo verse over Beach House's "Zebra." And Belgian disco bros Aeroplane will be holding it down in the dance tent all day long. Who wouldn't want to listen to those guys play records for 14 consecutive hours?

Allison Stewart:

Jay-Z/Thom Yorke ($200k - they could perform as Jaydiohead and split the money), Pavement ($100k), Dead Weather ($60k), Sleigh Bells ($20k), Beach House ($20k), B.o.B. ($20k), Corinne Bailey Rae ($20k), Girls ($20k), Delphic ($20k), Baroness ($20k)

First of all, I don't want any grief over my top choice: Hova and Thom Yorke? Why couldn't that be a thing? Otherwise, I tended to stick with cheaper bands - there are many hours to fill and a person can only spend so much time in the chill-out tent. Also, this being Coachella, I tried to make my list a mix of white hipster bands and other kinds of white hipster bands. I think I succeeded. I left out a lot of electronic acts - they tended to be more expensive. And it feels like rock's year, anyway.

Acts it killed me to leave out: Devo, Major Lazer, Wale, Gil Scott-Heron, MGMT, Spoon, Sly and the Family Stone

Act I easily did without because I do not like them: La Roux.

Sarah Godfrey:

Jay-Z ($200k), Sly and the Family Stone ($60k), De La Soul ($60k), Grace Jones ($40k), Gil Scott-Heron ($40k), John Waters ($40k), DJ Lance Rock ($40k), P.O.S. ($20k)

I spent most of my half-a-mil on hip-hop and soul here -- hey, it's what I like. Would I love to see Gossip or Dirty Projectors? Sure -- just not on my own (imaginary) dime. I thought long and hard about blowing $200,000 on Jay-Z and almost didn't -- I've seen him before and he'll mostly be doing material from "Blueprint 3," which I hate. But, if his set includes even one track from "Reasonable Doubt," I'll consider it money well spent.

Wale was hard to omit, but those of us in D.C. have opportunities to see him all the time. Faith No More was another toughie to leave off, as I was quite the fan back in junior high school, but I was unwilling to blow 1/5 of my budget on a nostalgic thrill. DJ Lance Rock is included because it'll help me impress all the little youngsters I know. Sly and John Waters are risky picks -- who knows what they'll do? -- but I couldn't not pick them, ya know?

David Malitz:

Pavement ($100k), LCD Soundsystem ($100k), Echo and the Bunnymen ($60k), Phoenix ($60k), Charlotte Gainsbourg ($60k), Grace Jones ($40k), Gil Scott-Heron ($40k), Sleigh Bells ($20k), The Soft Pack ($20k)

Two of us would be willing to spend a fifth of our budget on reunited indie rockers Pavement. (Photo courtesy Matador Records)

The headliners were obvious choices -- my favorite band of the '90s (Pavement) and one of my very favorites of the '00s (LCD Soundsystem). Plus, Echo and the Bunnymen is definitely on the shortlist for best of the '80s! Get a little French connection with Phoenix and Charlotte Gainsbourg, get some spectacle with Grace Jones. Gil Scott-Heron if only so James Murphy can introduce him by saying, "Gil! Scott! Heronnnnn!" Sleigh Bells to see what the buzz is about and the Soft Pack because I already know the buzz is deserved.

Bonus encore = Pavement and the Bunnymen teaming up on "The Killing Moon" with Malkmus and McCulloch trading verses. Swoon. I left off some indie rock faves -- Spoon, Yo La Tengo, Deerhunter -- because I've seen them all plenty of times and this wouldn't be the ideal setting, where as Phoenix and Grace Jones could really do it up on the big stage. Sly Stone was a tough omission, but I want my (fake) money to be well accounted for.

Who would play your dream Coachella? The (totally made-up) price points for each band are below. Share your ideal line-ups in the comments!

Jay-Z, Muse, Gorillaz

LCD Soundsystem, Them Crooked Vultures, Faith No More, Tiesto, Pavement, Thom Yorke????

Vampire Weekend, Deadmau5, Public Image Limited, the Specials, Grizzly Bear, Passion Pit, Echo and the Bunnymen, Benny Benassi, Fever Ray, MGMT, David Guetta, the Dead Weather, Hot Chip, Devo, Coheed and Cambria, Kaskade, 2ManyDJs, Major Lazer, Dirty Projectors, Gossip, Z-Trip, Phoenix, Orbital, Spoon, Sly and the Family Stone, De La Soul, Julian Casablancas, Plastikman, Gary Numan, Charlotte Gainsbourg

Grace Jones, She & Him, Erol Alkan, the Avett Brothers, Calle 13, the Whitest Boy Alive, the Cribs, La Roux, Yeasayer, Lucero, DJ Lance Rock, the Dillinger Escape Plan, Proxy, Ra Ra Riot, Deer Tick, Wolfgang Gartner, the xx, John Waters, Les Claypool, the Raveonettes, Mew, Sia, Camera Obscura, Tokyo Police Club, Porcupine Tree, Old Crow Medicine Show, Aterciopalados, Bassnectar, Frightened Rabbit, Dirty South, Sunny Day Real Estate, Yo La Tengo, MUTEMATH, Deerhunter, Infected Mushroom, Club 75, Matt & Kim, the Big Pink, Gil Scott-Heron, King Khan and the Shrines, Florence and the Machine, Yann Tiersen, Little Boots, Miike Snow

Aeroplane, Iglu & Hartley, Sleigh Bells, P.O.S., Baroness, Hockey, Little Dragon, White Rabbits, Wale, Kate Miller-Heidke, As Tall As Lions, Jets Overhead, Alana Grace, Pablo Hassan, Flying Lotus, Corinne Bailey Rae, Pretty Lights, Shooter Jennings, RX Bandits, the Almighty Defenders, Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeros, Craze & Klever, Zoe, the Temper Trap, Portugal. the Man, Band of Skulls, Girls, Beach House, Steel Train, Frank Turner, Talvin Singh, Ceu, B.o.B., Babasonicos, Owen Pallett, the Glitch Mob, Mayer Hawthorne, Local Natives, Rusko, the Middle East, Hadouken!, the Soft Pack, Kevin Devine, Paparazzi, Delphic, One EskimO

By David Malitz  |  January 21, 2010; 2:25 PM ET
Categories:  Taking sides  | Tags: Baroness, Beach House, Calle 13, Charlotte Gainsbourg, Coachella, Corinne Bailey Rae, De La Soul, Dead Weather, Dirty Projectors, Echo and the Bunnymen, Faith No More, Gil Scott-Heron, Girls, Grace Jones, Jay-Z, LCD Soundsystem, Pavement, Phoenix, Sleigh Bells, Sly Stone, Spoon, The Soft Pack, Thom Yorke, Wale  
Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   StumbleUpon   Technorati   Google Buzz   Previous: Local news: Haitian stars Tabou Combo to perform benefit concert at Kennedy Center
Next: In concert: Thievery Corporation


I like this exercise:

100k - LCD Soundsystem, Thom Yorke

60k - Passion Pit, Phoenix, De La Soul

40k - Yo La Tengo

20k - Beach House, POS, Wale, Edward Sharpe & The Magnetic Zeros

Toughest omissions: Pavement (would have picked them if I thought a big festival would suit them), Faith No More, MGMT, Spoon, Dirty Projectors, White Rabbits, and The Temper Trap (who I imagine would kill live)

Posted by: gocaps2 | January 21, 2010 2:54 PM | Report abuse

And Sly...who I would have added if I knew he'd show up and show up motivated.

Posted by: gocaps2 | January 21, 2010 3:02 PM | Report abuse

Nice one, Go Caps.

Posted by: ChrisRichards | January 21, 2010 3:03 PM | Report abuse

Ok, there is basically NO WAY Sly will pull off a good show. It is going to be like one of those terrible PBS doo-wop specials with off-pitch singing and an f'd up Sly slogging his way through the hits. SO:

Jay-Z (200k- the only person on the big list who warrants this kind of $$ for a live show)
PIL, Pheonix, Spoon -$60k each
Vampire Weekend- $60k, will be worth it to hear the constant drone of debate about the group from the critics (nerd) section backstage.
Gace Jones- $40k she will be better than the rest of the fest combined
Shooter Jennings-$20k I like the think of Shooter as the "diversity" in this line-up.

Posted by: josh18 | January 21, 2010 3:03 PM | Report abuse

Gorillaz (Playing their first album in its entirety - Dan The Automator + Del FTW)
Faith No More
Soft Pack

Posted by: leafblower | January 21, 2010 3:26 PM | Report abuse

200k-Gorillaz (they don't perform much, so it would be a treat)

100k-Them Crooked Vultures(Probably would have been a 200k band in Maca had been in it like he apparently wanted to be)

60k-Devo, De La Soul(Need a classic, and De La Soul is fun. They'd probably end up on stage with Groillaz)

40k-Porcupine Tree (They're blowing up, right?)

20k-Baroness(for a little metal)

Posted by: EricS2 | January 21, 2010 3:53 PM | Report abuse

$100k - Thom Yorke

$60k - Dead Weather, Sly and the Family Stone, Spoon

$40k - Aterciopelados, Les Claypool, The Raveonettes, Yeasayer, Yo La Tengo

I'll save the leftover $20k for next year's draft.

Posted by: Miles_Standish_Proud | January 22, 2010 5:32 PM | Report abuse

Les Claypool and Porcupine Tree? Y'all surprise me. In a good way. I think.

Posted by: ChrisRichards | January 22, 2010 5:39 PM | Report abuse

Pretty easy for me. Not thrilled with the headliners but plenty on the undercard I'd love to see:

Faith No More-100k
Public Image Limited-60k
The Specials-60k
De La Soul-60k
Dillinger Escape Plan-40k
King Khan and the Shrines-40k
Matt and Kim-40k
John Waters-40k

the Raveonettes

Posted by: dcmc8377 | January 23, 2010 9:05 AM | Report abuse

The comments to this entry are closed.

RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2010 The Washington Post Company