Speculation: Predicting Pitchfork's top 10 of 2010
One of our favorite December rituals is trying to predict Pitchfork’s year-end Top 10 list. They’ve made it much easier in recent years -- pretty much anyone can click through the site's Best New Music archive and see which albums earned the highest ratings.
Still, there are a few other factors to consider: (1) Pitchfork's numerous contributors each have a vote, so albums that appear on the most lists will rank highest. (2) Certain artists have gained or lost momentum over the course of the year, and that seems like it can effect their year-end score. And (3), Pitchfork appears to give bonus points to bands the site helped break.
With that in mind, here's a stab at this year's top 10.
1. Kanye West - “My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy”
Obviously. Kanye earned a unicorny 10.0. It's a lock.
2. Deerhunter - “Halcyon Digest”
Bradford Cox and friends are locked in a four-way tie with Big Boi, Joanna Newsom and LCD Soundsystem for 2010's second highest rating -- a 9.2 -- but this album seems likely to be on most lists.
3. Big Boi - “Sir Luscious Left Foot: The Son of Chico Dusty”
Two hip-hop albums in the top three? Makes sense in year when Pitchfork's awkward embrace of the genre grew tighter than ever before. For every new Tom Breihan review, there were three more that quoted an old Tom Breihan review.
4. LCD Soundsystem - “This Is Happening”
James Murphy's swansong may have ranked lower, had he not headlined July's Pitchfork Festival.
5. Ariel Pink’s Haunted Grafitti - “Before Today”
Longtime cult favorite finally releases the album everyone can get behind.
6. Joanna Newsom - “Have One On Me”
Huge rating early in the year, but how long did it stay in rotation?
7. Flying Lotus - “Cosmogramma”
There's always one out-of-left-field pick, usually of the experimental/electronic variety.
8. Beach House - “Teen Dream”
Seems like the right spot for an album that will be on plenty of lists, but not often at the tippy top.
9. Sleigh Bells - “Treats”
This stuff sure sounded a lot better in the summer than in winter, didn't it?
10. How to Dress Well - “Love Remains”
Did anyone care about this incredibly mediocre music before Pitchfork put its stamp on it? We're guessing they'll stand by their man -- even if he is a truly wretched singer.
David Malitz and Chris Richards
| December 2, 2010; 11:00 AM ET
Categories: Speculation | Tags: Big Boi, Deerhunter, Joanna Newsom, Kanye West, LCD Soundsystem, Pitchfork, Sleigh Bells
Save & Share: Previous: Grammy nominees announced; Raheem DeVaughn nominated for best R&B album; DC9 to reopen; Fans hold vigil for Aretha Franklin; Bono speaks on World AIDS Day
Next: On air: Washington Post pop music critic Chris Richards talks Grammys on WNYC's Soundcheck
Posted by: universaltravaler | December 2, 2010 11:49 AM | Report abuse
Posted by: tylerjeffries | December 2, 2010 1:45 PM | Report abuse
Posted by: ChrisRichards | December 2, 2010 3:12 PM | Report abuse
Posted by: agl132 | December 2, 2010 3:21 PM | Report abuse
Posted by: fangb | December 2, 2010 8:00 PM | Report abuse