Network News

X My Profile
View More Activity
Post Rock Archive  |  About the Bloggers  |  E-mail: Click Track  |  On Twitter: Click Track  |  RSS Feeds RSS
Posted at 1:54 PM ET, 01/18/2011

Album reviews: The Decemberists -- "The King Is Dead," Iron & Wine -- "Kiss Each Other Clean," Tennis -- "Cape Dory"

By Chris Richards

iron and wineYou're getting very sleepy ... Iron & Wine's Sam Beam.

Remember the aughties? It was a decade riddled with war anxiety, Internet fatigue and Gitmo shame.

Somehow, rock-and-roll became the security blanket that would protect us from this accelerating horde of American bummers. Coldplay filled stadiums with their comfort anthems, while the Shins defined threatening times with nonthreatening songs. (Then Ronald McDonald waved his magic freedom fry and turned one into a television ad.)

Elsewhere in indieland, a bothersome new type of escape-rock emerged, promising to lower your blood pressure while increasing your IQ. Its champions were Iron & Wine and the Decemberists, two acts that arrived in the early 2000s, armed with acoustic guitars and surplus copies of Roget's Thesaurus. Their lyrics were smart, their melodies were precious and it was all so boring. Now, both acts have new major label releases that venture into fresh turf but still feel uninspired.

Decemberist in chief Colin Meloy has sung plenty about war, but his stomach-turning fondness for lyrical archaisms and songs about medieval romance always gave the impression that he was living in the wrong century - or in the deluded fog of his own genius.

No surprise, then, that the new Decemberists album, "The King Is Dead," finds Meloy crooning about Gilded Age businesswoman Hetty Green and "supply-side bonhomie . . . in the year of the chewable Ambien tab."

Meloy seems to have chewed a few Ambien before heading into the studio. Easing up on the fussy progressive-folk loop-de-loops, this is a stripped-down, mercifully mellower Decemberists. "Don't Carry It All" sounds like Weezer checked in for a weekend at the Neutral Milk Hotel, while "Down by the Water" pantomimes R.E.M. to startling effect. Or maybe not that startling - R.E.M.'s Peter Buck actually plays guitar on the song (and Americana darling Gillian Welch sings backup).

But with all of the musical derring-do extracted from the mix, Meloy's most pretentious lyrics - "The thrushes bleating battle with the wrens/Disrupts my reverie again," for instance - feel particularly grating.

Sam Beam, who performs as indie-folk star Iron & Wine, faces the inverse problem. His lyrics hardly jump out from the pleasing sonic gristle of his new album, "Kiss Each Other Clean."

That's because this is a wonderfully recorded clutch of songs, full of rubbery bass lines, epileptic clavinet riffs and hyper-studied production values that fall somewhere between the soft rock of the '70s and the global-minded pop of the '80s. "Rabbit Will Run" might be Beam's finest five minutes - pliant vocals over plinking marimbas, whispering flutes and simmering cymbals.

But even beneath his most imaginative soundscapes flows a river of sap. As a singer, Beam is still afraid to use both lungs, and as a songwriter he's still allergic to adventure - a weakness evidenced with album-closer "Your Fake Name Is Good Enough for Me." It's an unexpected swatch of jaunty Afro-pop that inexplicably changes its wonderful tempo, scrapping all momentum for a plodding, prosaic grand finale. Just like that, a welcome left turn sadly corrects itself.

Will indie rock remain forever dull? Maybe. A new generation of bands is proving that the new boring is different from the old boring, but still kinda boring. Among them: Tennis, a Denver duo with 10 more songs you probably won't remember next week.

Most of the buzz surrounding the band's debut album, "Cape Dory," comes from its back story. In 2009, guitarist Patrick Riley and singer Alaina Moore, husband and wife, sailed a boat down the East Coast of the United States. When they got home, they started writing "Cape Dory."

But these aren't deck-swabbin' sea shanties - they're listless, Phil Spector-inspired tunes about the places they visited. The album's opening cut, "Take Me Somewhere," offers the closest Tennis ever gets to a hook. And isn't the song's titular refrain something we should be asking of them?

The quick ascent of easy-breezy groups such as Tennis shows that, from one decade to the next, the indie rock landscape has barely shifted beneath our espadrilles. Brainy, austere and quirky has given way only to clever, casual and quirky.

The security blanket has become a Snuggie.

Recommended tracks: Iron & Wine's "Rabbit Will Run," Tennis's "Take Me Somewhere"

By Chris Richards  | January 18, 2011; 1:54 PM ET
Categories:  Album reviews  | Tags:  Iron & Wine, Tennis, The Decemberists  
Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   StumbleUpon   Technorati   Google Buzz   Previous: Album review: White Lies, "Ritual"
Next: In concert: Patti LaBelle at the Kennedy Center


Hmmmm... some of the tags describing the recorded output of Iron and Wine and The Decemberists - "bothersome" "boring" "precious" and "uninspired" - pretty much like this entirely contrived and totally predictable review, then?
While I can understand not appreciating certain types of indie, to say that the above parties have been boring and uninspired throughout their careers borders on willful ignorance of the subject matter.
You sir, come across as a veritable billboard for holier-than-thou, too-cool-for-school hipster rock crits everywhere. So, well done, I guess.
Go back to listening to your beloved cheerleader-metal faves, Sleigh Bells, and leave the real music to the rest of us.

Posted by: skaboom | January 19, 2011 7:54 PM | Report abuse

Honestly, who do you think you are? What have you ever created to give you a basis for this critique?

Posted by: anti-critic | January 20, 2011 5:58 AM | Report abuse

Wow. I couldn't disagree more. So it's Lady Gaga for you I guess, seeing you hate indie rock. At least you gave the Smith Westerns and James Blake a fairer shake, although no review of "Dye It Blond"?

Posted by: beachmom | January 24, 2011 9:30 AM | Report abuse

Post a Comment

We encourage users to analyze, comment on and even challenge's articles, blogs, reviews and multimedia features.

User reviews and comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. Finally, we will take steps to block users who violate any of our posting standards, terms of use or privacy policies or any other policies governing this site. Please review the full rules governing commentaries and discussions.

characters remaining

RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2011 The Washington Post Company