Featured Item
Hillary the Underdog?

Hillary the Underdog?

Hillary Clinton: transformed from a potentially humiliated front-runner to a scrappy underdog?
Read on, weigh in »

Archives

Recent Posts

Candidates

Issues

Ratings

Regular Features

Stories By Date

Subscribe to This Blog

About the Fact Checker

"Comment is free, but facts are sacred." -- C.P. Scott, editor Manchester Guardian, 1921


Our goal is to shed as much light as possible on controversial claims and counter-claims involving important national issues and the records of the various presidential candidates. More »

Related Links

Campaign Resources on washingtonpost.com

More Useful Sites

Campaign 2008

The Trail

Method or the Map?

Was the New Hampshire primary rigged? 8:10 PM ET | More »

Candidate Watch

The Fibs of 2007


Rudy Giuliani with Margaret Thatcher, September 19, 2007.

One of the five "most famous" Americans?


In the spirit of the holiday season, I am inviting nominations for the "Top Ten Fibs of 2007". There are two categories in the competition: "Presidential Candidates" and "Best of the Rest." Post your nominations in the comments section or use the "Contact the Fact Checker" form. Also feel free to cast a non-binding vote for your favorite fib. The deadline is Friday, Dec. 28. A panel of crack Fact Checkers will select the Top Five Fibs in each category and post them online on Monday, December 31. We will also make a Geppetto truth-telling award in the "Presidential Candidates" category.


To kick the competition off, here are some early nominations (in no particular order):

Presidential Candidates:


  • "I'm probably one of the four or five best known Americans in the world."
  • --Rudy Giuliani, in London, Sept. 19. He mentioned Bill and Hillary Clinton as two other "well known Americans," but was whisked away by security men before he could be asked about Oprah Winfrey, Brad Pitt, Michael Jackson, Muhammad Ali, Bill Gates, George H.W. Bush and a host of others. (Nominated by Fred Shapiro, Editor, The Yale Book of Quotations.)

    ***

  • "I saw my father march with Martin Luther King."
  • --Mitt Romney, "Faith in America" address, Dec. 6. Debunked by the Boston Phoenix. Romney later said he was speaking "figuratively." (Nominated by Stephen Holmes.)

    ***

  • "I don't want to wake up four years from now and discover that we still have more young black men in prison than in college."
  • --Barack Obama, fund-raiser in Harlem, Nov. 29. Challenged by the Fact Checker. It is untrue that young black prisoners outnumber young black students.

    ***

  • ""They don't talk about [the NAFTA superhighway], and they might not admit it, but there's been money spent on it."
  • --Ron Paul, CNN-YouTube Debate, Nov. 28, challenged by the Fact Checker. The NAFTA superhighway is a myth.

    ***

  • New Mexico is "the only state that follows the Kyoto treaty."
  • --Bill Richardson, Stephanie Miller Radio Show, Nov. 7. Challenged by the Fact Checker. New Mexico is a long way from the Kyoto targets.

    ***

  • "My chances of surviving prostate cancer and thank God I was cured of it, in the United States, 82 percent. My chances of surviving prostate cancer in England, only 44 percent under socialized medicine."
  • --Rudy Giuliani, New Hampshire radio advertisement, Oct. 29. Challenged by the Fact Checker. Instead of correcting his mistake, Giuliani repeated it here.

    ***

  • NAFTA ... has cost us millions of jobs."
  • --John Edwards, CNN debate, Nov. 15, challenged by the Fact Checker. According to the Congressional Research Service, NAFTA had "little or no impact" on aggregate employment in the United States.

    ***

  • "Our first president and our first commander in chief prayed every day. [George Washington] had a field manual of prayers."
  • --Duncan Hunter, Fox News Channel, Oct. 31. Challenged by Politifact, which debunked the story about George Washington's personal prayerbook.

    Geppetto "truth-telling" Nominations:


  • "I am not perfect."
  • --Mitt Romney, YouTube/CNN debate, Nov. 28.

    ***

  • "The point was to inhale. That was the point."
  • --Barack Obama, Dec. 13, after the Clinton campaign raised questions about his drug use as a young man.

    ***

  • "I am not perfect, nor do I claim to be."
  • --John Edwards, Democratic Debate, Oct. 30.

    ***

  • "I wasn't there. I am sure it was a cultural and pharmaceutical event. I was tied up at the time."
  • --John McCain, Republican debate, Orlando, Oct. 21, criticizing Hillary Clinton for earmarking $1 million for a Woodstock museum.

    ***

  • "I am not a perfect candidate."
  • --Rudy Giuliani, campaigning in Michigan, Sept. 20.

    ***

    Best of the Rest:


  • "In Iran, we don't have homosexuals like in your country. ... In Iran we do not have this phenomenon."
  • --Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, Columbia University, Sept. 24.

    ***

  • "If we reported it, it's a fact."
  • --Lou Dobbs of CNN, interviewed by CBS's 60 Minutes, May 6, standing by a false claim that there had been 7,000 new cases of leprosy in the United States between 2002 and 2004, as a result of illegal immigration. His source: "medical expert" Madeleine Cosman.

    ***

  • "I'm a fairly wide guy. I tend to spread my legs when I lower my pants so they won't slide."
  • Sen. Larry Craig (R-Idaho), June 11, telling an undercover police officer in the Minneapolis-St. Paul airport why their feet touched in a public bathroom.

    ***

  • "Even though I approved of Afghanistan and opposed Iraq from the beginning, I still resent that I was not asked or given the opportunity to support those soldiers,"
  • --Bill Clinton, Nov. 27, insisting while campaigning with his wife in Iowa that he opposed the Iraq war, a claim at odds with his own statements at the time. (Nominated by Washington Post staff writer Peter Baker.)

    ***

  • "A lengthy occupation was, I believe, the single biggest mistake the United States made in Iraq."
  • --Douglas J. Feith, speech to American Enterprise Institute, Dec. 10, overlooking other bungled decisions on Iraq in which he played a key role as Undersecretary of Defense for Policy, including the original decision to invade the country. (Nominated by Washington Post staff writer Thomas E. Ricks.)

    ***

  • "Last question."
  • FEMA press secretary Aaron Walker, winding up a fake press conference on Oct. 23, at which the only questioners present were FEMA staffers. (Nominated by Washington Post staff writer Spencer S. Hsu.)

    ***

  • "The government does not torture people. ... We stick to U.S. law and international obligations."
  • President Bush, Oct. 5, responding to disclosure of a 2005 government memo that authorized simulated drowning, or "waterboarding." The United Nations Convention Against Torture, which came into force in 1985, defines torture as "any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining from him or a third person information or a confession." (Nominated by Fred Shapiro.)

    Posted on December 24, 2007 at 6:00 AM ET  | Category: Barack Obama, Bill Richardson, Candidate Record, Candidate Watch, Education, Gov Watch, History, Iraq, John Edwards, Mitt Romney, Ron Paul, Rudy Giuliani, Social Issues
    Share This: Technorati | Tag in Del.icio.us | Digg This | What Are These Links?
    Previous: Four Pinocchios for Romney on MLK | Next: Obama vs Clinton on Foreign Policy

    Comments

    Please email us to report offensive comments.



    you ought to include your own conclusions ,especially with the canidates you don't support

    Posted by: newagent99 | December 24, 2007 09:27 AM

    Has someone forgot President Bush when he stated Illegals only take jobs americans don't want? What a whopper that was.

    Posted by: budswisr | December 24, 2007 09:57 AM

    My dual nomination:

    "Mexico's gross domestic product, now more than $875 billion, has more than quadrupled since 1987."

    --Washington Post editorial, December 3, 2007.

    and

    "So take your pick. Depending on the statistics you use, Mexican economic growth over the last two decades has been either 337 percent, 125 percent, or 83 percent."

    Michael Dobbs, December 7

    Posted by: Alex | December 24, 2007 02:03 PM

    Two eye witnesses and four historical books have surfaced that deliver this message:

    "Any doubts on this score were dispelled on July 23, 1963 when a massive civil rights demonstration lead by Reverend King took place in Detroit. Between 150,000 and 200,000 people participated, about 90 per cent of them black...Mayor Cavanagh, Governor George Romney, and Walter Reuther were among the prominent whites marching with Reverend King."

    http://books.google.com/books?id=Fa_f3oz0Q2kC&pg=PA487&dq=%22Governor+George+Romney%22+%26+King&lr=&sig=GWo5eaPFVy1dyIMgA4eVSPCrQ14

    Posted by: Bryan | December 24, 2007 02:18 PM

    So every candidate has lied, but the "congenital liar." I guess fair and balanced went out the window.

    Posted by: mdyoung | December 24, 2007 03:05 PM

    There are 'fibs', and there are illegal coverups. From the London Times: The Justice Department has launched its own inquiry into the destruction of the tapes. It emerged yesterday that the CIA had misled members of the 9-11 Commission by not disclosing the existence of the tapes, in potential violation of the law. President George W Bush said last week he could not recall learning about the tapes before being briefed about them on December 6 by Michael Hayden, the CIA director.

    "It looks increasingly as though the decision was made by the White House," said Johnson. He believes it is "highly likely" that Bush saw one of the videos, as he was interested in Zubaydah's case and received frequent updates on his interrogation from George Tenet, the CIA director at the time.

    Posted by: e9999999 | December 24, 2007 04:14 PM

    The Justice Department has launched its own inquiry into the destruction of the tapes. It emerged yesterday that the CIA had misled members of the 9-11 Commission by not disclosing the existence of the tapes, in potential violation of the law. President George W Bush said last week he could not recall learning about the tapes before being briefed about them on December 6 by Michael Hayden, the CIA director.

    "It looks increasingly as though the decision was made by the White House," said Johnson. He believes it is "highly likely" that Bush saw one of the videos, as he was interested in Zubaydah's case and received frequent updates on his interrogation from George Tenet, the CIA director at the time.

    Posted by: e9999999 | December 24, 2007 04:14 PM

    Bush is in a catagory all His Own. He has told so many Lies that the real question should be, "Which of the Whoppers told by Bush killed the most People?" I'm aware all Presidents Lie but Bush seems to prefer lying to telling the truth. The old adage that "some People would rather lie than tell the truth, even if the truth sounded better" is a perfect description of George W.

    Posted by: MikeL | December 24, 2007 04:21 PM

    I think the Fact Checker is full of it. The NAFTA Superhighway will/will happen. The process is already underway. Dummy up!

    Posted by: Tupac Goldstein | December 24, 2007 04:22 PM

    Biggest Lie of 2007????

    That the Washington Post is checking facts for anything more than entertainment purposes.

    The Washington Post is still calling torture an "aggressive interogation technique".

    The Washington Post has never accounted for the lies they echoed from the administration that led us into Iraq. Instead, they carried the same administration lies about Iran and dropped the story about the president knowingly lying about Iran's nuclear threat.

    The Washington Post cited John Edwards because he said that "NAFTA had cost millions of American jobs". NAFTA has indeed cost millions of jobs, but the Post counted new jobs created in the hamburger flipping industry against the total and called him a liar!!

    The Washington Post constantly quote annonymous sources who lie for the administration and then deny accountability themselves because "somebody else" said those things!

    The winner of the 2007 LIAR of the Year Award goes to the biggest spreader of corporate manure in the world, "The Washington Post".

    Posted by: Kevin Morgan | December 24, 2007 04:33 PM

    I would like to nominate Sen. Hillary Clinton's justification for voting for Bush's war. She said, "Obviously, if we knew then what we know now, there wouldn't have been a vote and I wouldn't have voted that way." Actually, we DID know then what we know now. She simply chose to ignore the information that was available to everyone else, including ordinary citizens like me.

    Posted by: Patrick Fleeharty | December 24, 2007 05:07 PM

    While I have real concerns about the evident pro-Bush bias of the Fact Checker column, I would like to submit the following for consideration of the biggest fib, in the "best of the rest" category:

    Karl Rove: "The administration was opposed to voting on [the pre-war Iraq resolution] in the fall of 2002 [just prior to elections]". This statement was made on the Charlie Rose show on Nov. 21, and immediately contradicted by former Chief of Staff Andrew Card and former Press Secretary Ari Fleischer.

    Posted by: Crispin | December 24, 2007 05:13 PM

    As always, I'm amazed by the sheer ugliness of the people who take the time to log onto the WaPo site to complain about the Fact Checker's "pro-Bush bias" or the impending "NAFTA superhighway" or how Mitt Romney means well so shouldn't be held accountable for anything he actually says.

    My favorite fib not by Romney or Giuliani -- who are so arrogant that they can't envision anything good happening for which they weren't responsible -- has been Mike Huckabee's insistence that "most" of the 56 Founding Fathers "were clergymen." The true number: one.

    Posted by: MatthewB | December 24, 2007 05:50 PM

    Here's a good one:

    "Why is Iran doing this? Because it has its eye on a single prize: the bomb."

    How about this one:

    "In probably less than two years, Ahmadinejad will have the bomb."

    One more:

    "Which makes it all the more urgent that powerful sanctions be slapped on the Iranian regime."

    Can you name that Washington Post - sanctioned liar?

    Posted by: HeavyJ | December 24, 2007 08:09 PM

    Federal Legislation Overview
    For over ten years, NASCO has been developing a strong coalition of cities, counties, states, Canadian provinces, and private sector companies to lobby for federal funding and promote a "SuperCorridor" to address the transportation, trade and security needs from Canada, the United States and Mexico.
    We have assisted in the lobbying effort to bring hundreds of millions of dollars to the NASCO I-35 Corridor, resulting in High Priority Corridor status for I-35 in 1995 under the Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act (ISTEA). In addition, we successfully assisted in lobbying for the creation of two new categories under the Transportation Act of the 21st Century (TEA-21) - the National Corridor Planning & Development Program and the Coordinated Border Infrastructure Program.
    NASCO also successfully lobbied to take the Highway Trust fund "off-budget" which resulted in increased transportation formula funding for NASCO's corridor states.
    NASCO has received $2.5 million in Congressional funding from the United States Department of Transportation (USDOT) for the development of a technology and tracking project. The project will have a team approach, using members of NASCO as the primary participants in the project, to the extent possible. NASCO believes the deployment of a modern information system will reduce the cost, improve the efficiency, reduce trade-related congestion, and enhance security of cross-border and corridor information, trade and traffic.
    The NASCO "SuperCorridor Caucus" was formed on Capitol Hill to promote corridor development and to help secure NASCO legislative initiatives in both the authorization and appropriation processes.
    We continue to be recognized as the strongest International Trade Corridor Coalition on Capitol Hill, and we are the only Corridor Coalition with true international representation from Canada, the United States and Mexico.

    Posted by: Tupac Goldstein | December 24, 2007 09:29 PM

    I can't believe that Alberto Gonzales or Lurita Doan didn't make your list. But my nominee is Mr. Tanner, late of the Civil Rights division who said that ID requirements do not adversely affect black voters because "they die first".

    Posted by: deedeezee | December 24, 2007 09:40 PM

    Since, as Mr. Goldstein's posting shows, money has been spent on promoting the "NAFTA superhigway," you ought to remove the reference to Dr. Paul's statement from this list.

    Posted by: billinvirginia | December 25, 2007 02:08 PM

    Mr. McCain repeated what is an article of faith among many American evangelicals: "the Constitution established the United States of America as a Christian nation."

    Posted by: Kiku | December 26, 2007 02:57 AM

    After WaPo works out the bugs, as pointed out by previous posters, this might be a legitimate series.

    Even if it insists on trying to form your opinion.

    And the SuperCorridor is real, the 'NAFTA Superhighway' is not. Oh how they love to parse their words.

    WaPo ought to remove Ron Paul's so-called fib. He's one guy who's telling it like it is, for the most part.

    Posted by: chauncykat | December 26, 2007 08:18 PM

    My nomination:

    Rudy Giuliani:

    "I know that reducing taxes produces more revenues."

    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/12/01/AR2007120101615.html

    If that is true, why don't we reduce taxes to 1%? In fact economists from conservative Greg Mankiw to liberal Paul Krugman agree that this is NOT the case.

    Posted by: | December 27, 2007 10:32 AM

    The "NAFTASuperhighway" might not be real. However, something very like it - except for the name - is definitely being planned. And, as the Goldstein comment points out, money has indeed been spent not only on that but on the TransTexasCorridor. Mexico wants to extend that south to their ports, and the Canadian has even confirmed the northern part of the scheme:

    http://lonewacko.com/blog/archives/007290.html

    I guess Michael Dobbs or his bosses have too much invested in denying the existence of something that quite clearly is real. Some fact checker.

    Posted by: LonewackoDotCom | December 27, 2007 04:46 PM

    I am very glad that Mike Huckabee didn't make the list.

    Posted by: GK | January 13, 2008 05:02 PM

    Post a Comment

    We encourage users to analyze, comment on and even challenge washingtonpost.com's articles, blogs, reviews and multimedia features.

    User reviews and comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. Finally, we will take steps to block users who violate any of our posting standards, terms of use or privacy policies or any other policies governing this site. Please review the full rules governing commentaries and discussions.




     

    Contact the Fact Checker

    We rely on our readers to send us suggestions on topics to fact check and tips on erroneous claims by political candidates, interest groups and the media. If you have facts or documents that shed more light on a subject under discussion, or if you think we have made a mistake, let us know.

    If you wish to send an attachment, please e-mail factchecker@washpost.com.

     

    © 2006-2007 The Washington Post Company