Network News

X My Profile
View More Activity
Posted at 6:00 AM ET, 05/20/2008

John McCain's Birthplace

By Michael Dobbs


Mother's Day Video.

"John McCain, widely reported to have been born in the Panama Canal Zone in the Coco Solo Naval Hospital, COULD NOT have been born in Coco Solo Hospital and probably wasn't born in the Canal Zone at all."
--News Busters blog, Feb. 21, 2008.

Some bloggers are questioning John McCain's right to run for the presidency on the basis of his birth in the Panama Canal Zone. They have produced "evidence" showing that that the hospital where the Arizona senator says he was born was not built until 1941--five years after McCain's birth. A review of the archival record shows that there was a small hospital at the Coco Solo submarine base in 1936 and also reveals the name of the U.S. Navy physician who signed McCain's birth certificate.

The Facts

I dealt with the constitutional debate on whether McCain is a "natural born citizen" in a previous post. (According to the Constitution, only "natural born citizens" have the right to run for the presidency.") The senator bases his eligibility claim on the fact that he was (1) born on a military base in the Panama Canal Zone at a time when it was effectively under U.S. sovereignty and (2) both of his parents were U.S. citizens.

As I reported earlier, the McCain campaign has declined to publicly release the senator's birth certificate. But a senior campaign official showed me a copy of his birth certificate issued by the "family hospital" in the Coco Solo submarine base. (McCain's grandfather commanded the Coco Solo Naval Air Station in 1936; his father was the executive officer of a submarine based in Coco Solo.)

The birth certificate was signed by Captain W. L. Irvine. I have now checked that name against the Naval Register for 1936, and I find that William Lorne Irvine was director of the medical facility at the submarine base hospital in Coco Solo, Panama Canal Zone, during that time period. You can see the entry here. I think this effectively disposes of any remaining doubts that McCain was born inside the Canal Zone.

The senator's 96-year-old mother, Roberta McCain, recalled the occasion in a Mother's Day video available here. She recalled "the 27 bottles of Scotch" stacked on a table of the nearby Officers' Club, gifts to her husband in celebration of the arrival of "the sweetest, nicest child I have ever known."

The Pinocchio Test

There is a valid constitutional debate about what the Founding Fathers had in mind when they decided that only "natural born" citizens should be eligible for the presidency. But there is no foundation for the rumors that have surfaced on the Internet that John McCain was born in the Panamanian city of Colon, rather than inside the U.S.-administered Panama Canal Zone.

(About our rating scale.)

By Michael Dobbs  | May 20, 2008; 6:00 AM ET
Categories:  4 Pinocchios, History, Web Watch  
Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   Del.icio.us   StumbleUpon   Technorati   Google Buzz   Previous: Golf-gate!
Next: McCain, Obama, and Kissing Dictators

Comments

dxinuadw1 http://www.275836.com/1072307.html > tpo846higobgzcejo [URL=http://www.892462.com/713462.html] 3ia7wrzl4i9m [/URL] v3c7txff06ii

Posted by: gmvje13tek | May 20, 2008 6:33 AM | Report abuse

Here is another gutless "Fact Checker". Nobody that matters is really debating this point. This is a non-issue.

On the other hand, -White House Official Slams NBC Over "Appeasement" Coverage- seem perfect for discussion.

Posted by: vcsmith | May 20, 2008 7:27 AM | Report abuse

Shouldn't you be giving McCain a Geppetto, rather than give the bloggers four Pinocchios? Seems like a rather negative way to say that McCain is legit to run for presidency.

Posted by: Dan | May 20, 2008 11:25 AM | Report abuse

Let me preface by saying that neither Sen. Clinton nor Sen. Obama were my 1st, 2nd, or 3rd choice for Democratic nominee.

Casual readers of the "Fact Checker" might assume, from its title and from its sponsorship by the Washington Post, that this blog is intended to be essentially neutral or non-partisan. But the reality is that Mr. Hobbs has a very strong pro-Republican bias. For many many weeks, the "Featured Item" has been "Top 10 Democratic Flip-Flops." Even though Sen. McCain's flip-flops have been multiple, ongoing, and well-documented (but not by Mr. Hobbs), there hasn't been a posting on "Top 10 Republican Flip-Flops" -- let alone a perennial running head -- since February.

There have been considerably more than twice as many "fact checks" on Sens. Clinton and Obama than on Sen. McCain or the Bush Administration, and the "fact checks" on Sen. McCain have primarily been on non-issues, such as the precise circumstances of his birth. Just this past week alone, there have been many vastly more substantive issues of Sen. McCain's campaign whose facts need to be checked -- and have been, but not by Mr. Hobbs. Mr. Hobbs chose to check the facts about Rev. Wright's claims, even though Rev. Wright is not running for anything. But inexplicably, except for bias, he has not bothered check the facts around the preachers, Mr. Hagee and Mr. Parsley, among others, whom Sen. McCain went out of his way to court.

"Media Matters" makes no secret of its leanings. The Fact Checker clearly does. It seems to me that Mr. Hobbs should award himself a good handful of Pinochio's. And perhaps he might consider either changing the title of his blog or covering both campaigns comparably.

Posted by: EdA | May 20, 2008 11:41 AM | Report abuse

EdA:

I am a registered Independent, and it is obvious to me that Mr. Dobbs slams both sides. Could the fact that "Dems Flip Flops" or that they get more attention be based on their continued race, rather than some GOP bias. Dobbs has been dealing with all of the embarrassing McCain stuff too. I would be very surprised if McCain has much less than 1/3 of the "Fact Checker" threads since the first of the year.

Posted by: JakeD | May 20, 2008 1:42 PM | Report abuse

Citizen McCain
The Senate has declared that John McCain is a "natural-born citizen," eligible to be president of the United States. But the non-binding Senate resolution does not resolve an arcane constitutional debate about the meaning of "natural-born."

Posted on May 2, 2008 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (42)

Guilt by Association
Despite decrying the practice of "guilt by association," John McCain has been using the tactic a lot on the campaign trail recently. The Fact Checker looks at his rhetoric.

Posted on May 1, 2008 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (89)

A holiday from gas prices?
John McCain and Hillary Clinton are calling for a "gas tax holiday." Barack Obama calls the idea a "short-term quick fix" that won't help consumers. Who is right?

Posted on April 29, 2008 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (154)

Dr. Obama and Dr. McCain
Barack Obama and John McCain both believe there is good evidence of a link between autism and childhood vaccines. The medical establishment says otherwise.

Posted on April 22, 2008 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (60)

Cindy's Recipegate
At least four McCain "family recipes" featured on the campaign website turn out to have been cribbed from the Internet. The McCain campaign is using the "clueless intern" defense.

Posted on April 15, 2008 at 02:58 PM ET | Comments (29)

Still no light at the end of the tunnel
A rare Geppetto checkmark to General Petraeus and Ambassador Crocker for acknowledging that there is still no "light at the end of the tunnel" in Iraq. The three remaining presidential candidates have been less honest about the flaws in their own Iraqi exit strategies.

Posted on April 9, 2008 at 01:55 PM ET | Comments (30)

Name, Rank, and Service Number
A new television ad paints a picture of a defiant John McCain resisting his North Vietnamese captors. But it omits some important context. The Fact Checker investigates.

Posted on April 3, 2008 at 02:03 PM ET | Comments (95)

McCain's '100-year war'
Barack Obama continues to claim on the campaign trail that John McCain wants to fight a 100-year war in Iraq. Both he and Hillary Clinton have twisted McCain's words.

Posted on April 2, 2008 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (164)

McCain's Foreign Policy 'Gaffe'
Did John McCain mix up Sunnis and Shiites? Is there evidence to show that Iran (a Shiite theocracy) supports Sunni extremist groups in Iraq? The Fact Checker investigates.

Posted on March 20, 2008 at 11:38 AM ET | Comments (51)

Pinocchios for John McCain
John McCain has claimed that he is the "only" presidential candidate not to receive money from "special interests". Is he telling the truth?

Posted on February 29, 2008 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (49)

Bombs Away!
Macho alert! John McCain suggested changing the Beach Boys song "Barbara Ann" to "Bomb, bomb, Iran." But he is blasting Barack Obama for talking about bombing al Qaeda targets in Pakistan.

Posted on February 21, 2008 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (36)

John McClinton?
A new Romney ad depicts John McCain and Hillary Clinton as almost identical. We look at his facts.

Posted on February 7, 2008 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (28)

Who is the Champion Flip-flopper?
Who is the champion flip-flopper? On the eve of Super Tuesday, we take a look at the records of Mitt Romney and John McCain.

Posted on February 5, 2008 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (51)

GOP Debate, Jan. 30, 2008.
Join the Fact Checker and diplomatic reporter Glenn Kessler for live truth squadding of tonight's GOP debate from the Reagan Library in Simi Valley, CA.

Posted on January 30, 2008 at 06:08 PM ET | Comments (64)

Partial Quote Alert!
The art of the partial quote is alive and well in the 2008 presidential campaign. The Fact Checker digs up some recent examples of an old advertising trick.

Posted on January 29, 2008 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (11)

McCain attacks Romney on Iraq
John McCain has accused Mitt Romney of wanting to set a date for the withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq. He has distorted his rival's actual words.

Posted on January 28, 2008 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (495)

The GOP debate in Florida
Bloopers from the GOP debate in Florida. The candidates avoided challenging each other's records directly, but still made a number of questionable statements.

Posted on January 25, 2008 at 12:20 PM ET | Comments (74)

GOP Debate Myrtle beach
The Fact Checker and diplomatic reporter Glenn Kessler truth squad the Republican presidential debate from Myrtle Beach, South Carolina.

Posted on January 10, 2008 at 07:40 PM ET | Comments (10)

NH: One Day to Go
One day to the New Hampshire primary. The Fact Checker is on the road, following the candidates.

Posted on January 6, 2008 at 10:36 AM ET | Comments (29)

Saint Anselm College Presidential Debates
Join the Fact Checker for live truth squadding of the Republican and Democratic debates from Saint Anselm College in New Hampshire.

Posted on January 5, 2008 at 10:44 PM ET | Comments (44)

The 2007 Pinocchio Awards
The Fact Checker announces the 2007 Pinocchio Awards and a special Geppetto prize for truth-telling.

Posted on December 31, 2007 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (55)

Most Revealing Fibs: John McCain
A squabble over supply side economics appears to have broken out on board the "Straight Talk Express," pitting John McCain against his top domestic policy adviser. The Fact Checker adjudicates.

Posted on December 13, 2007 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (4)

'Bomb, Bomb, Bomb; Bomb, Bomb, Iran'
Some presidential candidates have claimed flatly on the campaign trail that Iran is developing nuclear weapons. But their assertions are undercut by the latest National Intelligence Estimate released yesterday.

Posted on December 4, 2007 at 06:00 AM ET | Comments (43)

One Up, One Down for John McCain
The Fact Checker awards his first Geppetto checkmark, along with three Pinocchios, to the inventor of the Straight Talk Express.

Posted on October 31, 2007 at 08:45 AM ET | Comments (9)

http://blog.washingtonpost.com/fact-checker/candidates/john_mccain/

Posted by: JakeD | May 20, 2008 2:36 PM | Report abuse

LMGTS: Natural born means?

Sorry but I totally disagree with the authors assertions. "Natural born" is only referenced once in qualifications of elected Federal offices - ONCE - For President of the United States. Therefore, its a far stretch of the imagination to conclude that it means anything other than what it implies. BORN ON AMERICAN SOIL.

A foreign military zone, IS NOT SOVEREIGN -- It is LEASED. THE PANAMA ZONE wasNEVER USA TERROITRY - EVER.

Certain rules apply to certain people one supposes.

History will bemadeifJohn MCCain becomes president - The only elected presdient NOT NATURAL BORN.

The bloggers have it half-correct.

In any case, Iam a registered Arizona Republican - LIFELONG and VET and I WILL NOT VOTE FOR MCCAIN.(More reasons exists than his place of birth - DIG DEEPER MSM- Deeper.)

Posted by: Lee GIABENELLI | May 20, 2008 4:32 PM | Report abuse

Sorry, JakeD,

If you look at your own list, you'll see how few and how old most of your cites are, with, realistically, only "Guilt by Association" (which was followed by a couple of columns on facts checked with respect to Rev. Wright, and nothing on McCain's own ministers of hate) and the join Clinton-McCain pander on the gas tax relevant and recent. And there is no excuse for not alternative Democrat and Republican "Top Ten Flipflops."

Regards,

Posted by: EdA | May 20, 2008 5:32 PM | Report abuse

Well, that's not an exhaustive list, EdA. It was just the first 30 I could find. I will leave it to Mr. Dobbs to respond to your charges, if need be.

Posted by: JakeD | May 20, 2008 6:45 PM | Report abuse

"Natural born" refers to having US citizenship at birth as opposed to acquiring it through naturalization. A person can be born anywhere in the world to US citizen parents and still be a natural born US citizen.

Posted by: MM | May 20, 2008 9:41 PM | Report abuse

McCaine is so old... for his first birthday his parents gave him fire.

Posted by: pubichaironmycokecan | May 21, 2008 1:15 AM | Report abuse

EdA:

Did you see the latest "Fact Checker" slamming McCain?

Posted by: JakeD | May 21, 2008 11:10 AM | Report abuse

Which one might that be JakeD...
The one about Israel "appeasing" Syria in Turkey...

Posted by: isupreme | May 21, 2008 1:07 PM | Report abuse

The comments to this entry are closed.

 
 
RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2011 The Washington Post Company