Even With Tomlin Move, Still Not a Great Hiring Cycle for Diversity

The Indianapolis Colts' Tony Dungy and the Chicago Bears' Lovie Smith have become the first two African-American head coaches to lead their teams to the Super Bowl.

The Pittsburgh Steelers hired a black head coach this week, Minnesota Vikings defensive coordinator Mike Tomlin.

But overall, it still hasn't been a great few weeks for diversity among NFL head coaches.

The league had a record seven black head coaches this season. But two of them, the Arizona Cardinals' Dennis Green and the Oakland Raiders' Art Shell, were fired after the season. Tomlin is the only minority coach among the five newly hired head coaches league-wide.

Former NFL commissioner Paul Tagliabue expressed disappointment last year when only two minority coaches were among the 10 coaches hired league-wide in that hiring cycle. The ratio hasn't improved during this hiring cycle, with the Dallas Cowboys now launching their search for a replacement for Bill Parcells.

By Mark Maske |  January 23, 2007; 5:04 PM ET  | Category:  Diversity
Previous: Grimm Lands in Arizona | Next: Suggestions for the Cowboys

Comments

Please email us to report offensive comments.



Why are there no Samoan coaches? No Samoans are being interviewed. Its racist against Samoans.

Posted by: Rocky | January 23, 2007 5:17 PM

20% of the coaches hired this year are black coaches. The US population is 12.9% black (per U.S. census 2000). Clearly blacks are overrepresented. The total "minority" population of the U.S. is approximately 30%. Clearly the NFL is under-represented by Latinos, Asian-Pacific Islanders, and Inuit-Native Americans. There are NO female or trans-gendered head coaches--clearly the NFL is discriminating moreso against these groups. Clearly we must expand the Rooney rule to include at least one Inuit and and one Fijian candidate for every head coaching position. Clearly we need to expand the Rooney Rule to include one transgendered and two female candidates for every position.

Posted by: load of crap | January 23, 2007 5:56 PM

My bad. Rocky, Samoan not Fijian.

Posted by: load of crap | January 23, 2007 5:57 PM

What ratio does the NFL desire? Parity with US demographics, with NFL viewership, or with the NFL players demographics. As was stated, the ratio of black head coaches already exceeds that of the US population. To reach parity with NFL players should the owners agree to fire half of their head coaches for the sake of parity ignoring the quality of their job performance?

NFL coaching is an elite club. Just 32 positions, period. This is not enough to ever fairly reflect parity of the country or the world. If you want to expand the list to include all coaching position in the NFL then we have a large enough number to look at.

Posted by: Jay | January 23, 2007 6:08 PM

why aren't there more hispanic and asian players?

Posted by: jimmy | January 23, 2007 6:46 PM

A minority of players are white. What racists forces are keeping the white man down?

Posted by: Rick | January 23, 2007 6:53 PM

Frankly, I think white sportswriters are over-represented -- this is what the NFL should be targeting.

Oh, and the Raiders are still the only team to have hired an African-American coach, an Hispanic Coach and the CEO is a woman (Amy Trask).

Posted by: RaiderFan | January 23, 2007 7:13 PM

Oh, and the Raiders are still the only team to have hired an African-American coach, an Hispanic Coach and the CEO is a woman (Amy Trask).

And how's that working out for them?

I can't get worked up about some supposed racist bias by the owners just because Denny Green and Art Shell got fired. Their firings are actually a good thing for black coaches - those two retreads won't be taking up the "Rooney Rule" spots anymore, clearing a path for some GOOD black coaches.

Posted by: Marc Nelson Jr. | January 23, 2007 7:37 PM

As far as racial discrimination in NFL coaching, I believe it is informative to listen to the lived experiences of an exceptional individual such as Tony Dungy. Only by seeing the harm inflicted on such individuals, will hearts be changed. Affirmative action may not quickly change racist attitudes since it engenders resentment from majority culture, but it does set social expectations of ethical behavior which over time can become the new social norms.

Posted by: davbeatty | January 23, 2007 9:07 PM

Some of you are idiots and can't even follow your own logic. When discussing the representative population of black football coaches, you should relate that to the NFL's player demographics and not to the TOTAL population of the US. The percentage of black coaches/GM's is FAR, FAR less than the percentage of black NFL players. Period.

Posted by: Dr. Pimpinstein | January 24, 2007 2:16 PM

This should stir a few radicals up:

What ever happened to the "Best Man for the Job" concept?

Aren't you people that insist a minority (of any kind) be given preferential treatment "Racists" by definition?

Have fun with that folks ... let the knives and daggers commence flying ...

Posted by: BoltsFan | January 24, 2007 2:53 PM

How do you know who the true "best man" for the job is if members of a certain population can't even get in the door to demonstrate their potential "best man" status. Unless of course the "best man for the job" is really coda for the best white man for the job.

Before the Rooney rule many black coaches weren't even getting interviewed. How many times did Dungy get passed over for jobs without even an interview? Was that because he was never the "best man for the job"? Meanwhile, several coaches who were hired have washed out of the league and Dungy is in the Super Bowl. I'll bet some of those owners wish they were "forced" to interview Dungy.

The Rooney rule is actually pretty fair. It's not mandating that black people get hired at all. Instead it's saying they just be included in the interview process. If an owner is hell bent on hiring a white man that's his choice but he may tell another owner that black coach x is a good candidate. Now black coach x is in the pipeline and has a chance at opportunities that he didn't have before.

Posted by: Omar | January 24, 2007 5:13 PM

I truly believe that Norv Turner deserves another shot at coaching. Look what he's done with DC and Oakland. I would definitely hire him if I were the Dallas owner. *must keep straight face*

Posted by: Steelers Fan | January 24, 2007 7:43 PM

Nevermind racial bias what about sexual preference discrimination? Why are there not more transexuals gracing our sidelines?

Posted by: Robb | January 31, 2007 1:02 PM

The comments to this entry are closed.

 
 

© 2008 The Washington Post Company