A Homestate's Skepticism
By Juliet Eilperin
While former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney is counting on his home state of Michigan to deliver him a key primary win next week, he faces fierce competition from both the left and the right in the form of Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) and former Arkansas governor Mike Huckabee.
Some Republican moderates in Michigan who backed Romney's father, George, the state's governor in the 1960s, view his son's emphasis on conservative values with skepticism.
"I was an original Romney girl," said JoAnn VanTassel, who served as township supervisor of Lake Orion, Mich. and is backing McCain. "I knew both George and Lenore Romney. I don't think George would approve of the way he's campaigning. I think his mother would take him to the woodshed."
At the same, Huckabee is relying on western Michigan's considerable network of evangelical leaders to help bolster his showing there, even as he campaigns in South Carolina. Rep. Fred Upton (R-Mich.), a McCain supporter whose district lies in the southwest part of the state, said some of his longtime supporters are moving toward Huckabee, an ordained minister.
"I've got some good supporters who have jumped on his bandwagon just in the last few weeks," Upton said. "But there's not that much time."
In some cases, this religious outreach has backfired. The associate pastor of the Beverly Reform Church in Wyoming, Mich., sent out an e-mail a few weeks ago to members of the evangelical congregation. Gayle Vanderzee, one of the church's parishioners and a McCain supporter, questioned why the pastor would endorse "a specific candidate."
"I know a number of people who received that message and were offended that he used his position" to conduct a political act. Those kinds of endorsements, she added, don't address public policy questions.
"It's strictly based on his Christian morals and values," she said. "They don't say anything about his stand on the issues."
Unlike Huckabee, who is devoting most of his time to wooing South Carolina voters, Romney is hustling to make an impression on Michigan Republicans before they head to the polls Tuesday. Just this week, his staff called organizers of the Berrien County Lincoln Day Dinner to see if he could attend the event Saturday night: he's now got it on his schedule.
Still, Upton warned, Romney should not count on his last name to win over Michiganders. His brother Scott Romney ran unsuccessfully for Michigan attorney general in 1998 (losing in a party caucus to a Republican with the politically catchy name of John Smietanka, who ended up losing in the general). And Scott Romney's ex-wife Ronna lost four years earlier when she ran in the GOP Senate primary. Spencer Abraham bested her and eventually wrested the seat from Democrat Bob Carr.
Posted at 5:51 PM ET on Jan 10, 2008
Share This:
Technorati
| Tag in Del.icio.us | Digg This

Get This Widget >>

Posted by: mrmillet | January 11, 2008 3:43 PM
Mike Huckabee is a democrat in republican trousers.
In last night's FOX debate, Huckabee continued to evade the facts about his record in cutting taxes over 90 times as the governor of Arkansas.
[What he did not say was that taxes rose overall during his ten year stint, which ended earlier this year. According to the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette of October 9, 2007, he presided over a net tax increase of $505 million while he was governor. The state Department of Finance and Administration counted 21 tax increases that raised revenues by $883 million. - WaPo Fact Checkers]
Add that to increasing the government in Arkansas and pushing his policy to provide free scholarships to the students of illegals shows his true colors. And, if evangelical pastors are crossing the church/state boundaries by actively promoting Huchabee, they should pay a severe fine and be taxed.
I like Thompson's views on the Fair Tax. He states that the Fair Tax is worth looking into; however, the government would have to pass legislation to abolish any other taxes being levied on American citizens and he doesn't see that happening. I, for one, don't even like the thought of being taxed twice. Think about it.
Romney is looking better each time I hear him. It's like my wife says, "Don't hate Mitt because he is beautiful, intelligent, and rich. Put him to work. Send him to the White House." Aye... she's a smart lady.
Posted by: astevens-OH | January 11, 2008 2:37 PM
Huckabee is the best man for the times we face. He is comfortable being himself more than any other candidate.
In Michigan, Huckabee is the only Republican who focuses on the struggle people are going through.
He also has bold proposals that will help Michigan's ailing economy. He wants to achieve energy independence in 10 years-- a very agressive schedule to be sure! But that means more dollars for research into alternative technologies, especially in the auto industry. He wants to help America reclaim technological leadership in this area, to lead the world and generate new jobs and income.
On the tax side, he is NOT a tax-and-spender as some insist. The taxes he raised in Arkansas funded long-overdue improvements in education and roads... two of the most legitimate functions of the state government. As a President, he'll try to return more control to the states to do as he did in Arkansas. He's signed the no new tax pledge, and is supporting another bold idea, the FairTax.
The FairTax would help level the playing field between Detroit and foreign automakers. Foreign firms get an advantage because most countries have much lower corporate tax rates than the U.S. The application of tax at the consumption end means the foreign cars pay just as much tax as the domestic ones.
Posted by: geckor | January 11, 2008 12:01 PM
Some other thoughts re: Huckabee being too liberal on issues such as poverty, health care and the environment -- Southern Baptist Convention President Frank Page, a pastor in Taylors, S.C. dismissed those criticisms, while not endorsing anyone, he called Huckabee a "caring, genuine, humble person."
Among the state's 700,000 Southern Baptists, support for Huckabee is still mixed, but many now view him as an electable candidate who shares their evangelical values, said Page: "Baptists are pragmatists who support those who they believe to be electable and consistent with pro-family policies."
In the final campaign stretch in South Carolina, Huckabee backers will distribute voter guides and air radio announcements urging Christian pastors to speak out on moral issues and encourage people to vote, said Janet Folger, a Florida-based talk show host and co-chair of Huckabee's Faith and Family Values Coalition.
http://apnews.myway.com/article/20080110/D8U39RA01.html
What is wrong with Christians exercising their First Amendment rights?
Posted by: JakeD | January 10, 2008 8:40 PM
Of course, no self-respecting church would specifically endorse Huckabee by name. I agree that would be a violation ; )
Posted by: JakeD | January 10, 2008 8:33 PM
A church which is part of a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organization is not permitted to lobby for or endorse any candidate. If any person's church or pastor is endorsing Huckabee (or any political candidate) or encouraging others to vote for him, that is grounds for the church losing its 501(c)(3) status. Thus, the church could lose its tax-exempt status and be forced to pay for sales tax, property tax, income tax, etc. Please tell your churches to stop endorsing Huckabee or they will face the consequences from the IRS!
Posted by: cbotros | January 10, 2008 7:56 PM
So are you saying that the "fierce competition" from the left is McCain or Huckabee? At least Huckabee is on the record DEFENDING THE FIRST AMENDMENT against McCain-Feingold! I really don't understand why people think Huckabee is such a LIBERAL -- Ronald Reagan made most of the same mistakes as Mike -- but, that doesn't make Reagan a "liberal" does it?
Posted by: JakeD | January 10, 2008 5:56 PM
The comments to this entry are closed.

An honest critique of each candidate will put Romney at the top of the pile in terms of more conservative. Unfortunatly, many people are not interested, or informed enough about political and economic realities to understand the differences and implications of a Huckabee policy vs. a Romney or McCain policy. In a time of uncertainty, it's no surprise people are looking for a populist message to calm their concerns. I would suggest however that they look past their immediate emotions and consider who is best to lead this country and whose policies can lead to lasting growth and a stronger country in general. Mitt Romney is that leader.