Favorite Hotels -- or Not

Ritz Carlton nudged just ahead of JW Marriott and Four Seasons as the favorite luxury hotel of guests surveyed by JD Powers, an information agency. The 46,634 guests who were questioned also rated their favorite hotels in upscale, midscale, budget and extended stay categories.
The just-released 2007 North America Hotel Guest Satisfaction Study, the 11th annual such report conducted by Powers, also reveals some interesting concerns hotel guests share.
Examples:
* While 97 percent of guests feel that they are safe or very safe in hotels in North America, only 65 percent said they felt safe in hotels outside North America.
* 73 percent of guests participate in enviromentally friendly programs offered by hotels.
* Staff attitude is the most frequently problems hotel guests report.
* The one amenity guests value most: complimentary breakfast.
* 82 percent of those surveyed said they prefer a smoke-free hotel.
The favored hotels tracked closely with the results in previous surveys.
1. In the upscale category, the most preferred were Embassy Suites, then Renaissance and Marriott.
2. Among mid-scale full service hotels, highest ratings went to Hilton Garden Inn, then Courtyard and Four Points by Sheraton.
3. Mid-scale hotels with limited service: Drury Inn & Suites, Hampton Inn, Springhill Suites.
4. In the economy grouping: Microtel Inns, Red Roof and Super 9 Motel.
5. Extended Stay Properties: Homewood Suites, Residence Inn, and Staybridge Suites.
For more details, check out a summary of the survey here.
Anyone beg to differ with some of these findings? Are there hotel chains you feel strongly about, pro or con?
By Gary Lee |
July 26, 2007; 10:22 AM ET
| Category:
Gary Lee
,
Hotels
Previous: MaxJet Feedback, Please |
Next: Elvis: Dead for 30 Years?!?!?
View or post comments
Posted by: Sean | July 26, 2007 11:23 AM
I've been a customer service trainer, and IMHO Ritz Carlton consistently scores highly precisely because of its emphasis on customer service. Problems encountered at a property that values its customers are easily forgotten when they are resolved quickly, effectively and with the utmost respect for the guest. EVERYONE employed at a Ritz-Carlton seems to live and breath this philosophy, and if other businesses (both in and out of the hospitality arena) followed their example the world would be a much nicer place.
Posted by: Karen | July 26, 2007 11:38 AM
Must say that we had a very nice stay at Staybridge Suites, and the breakfast was so good and so varied that we were able to stretch it into a few lunches, too.
Posted by: RealCalGal | July 26, 2007 12:23 PM
I've stayed at a lot of hotel chains, and my worst experience EVER was at a Wynn chain hotel. The "non-smoking" room reeked of cigarette smoke and deoderizer, the windows didn't open, the TV remote and water faucets didn't work, etc. etc. When I requested a room change (something I've never done before), they refused. All this despite having one of the most sumptuous hotel lobbies I've ever seen. That was five years ago, and the experience was so bad that I will never stay at that chain again. I've generally had good luck at the Embassy suites, Best Western, Marriot, and a number of others.
Posted by: TEL | July 26, 2007 2:53 PM
I'd easily put free WiFi and a good gym ahead of complimentary breakfast on the amenity scale.
Posted by: Andy | July 26, 2007 3:09 PM
Your "here" link links to this:
http://prn.newscom.com/cgi-bin/pub/s?f=PRN/prnpub
What's up with that?
Posted by: Anonymous | July 26, 2007 4:20 PM
Link's working now. Give it a look.
Posted by: post.com | July 26, 2007 4:40 PM
JD Power surveys should be taken with a grain of salt. BMW took a big hit because of cup holders and brake dust for reliability. Sorry what do cup holders have to do with reliability. Ritz has by far the best service in hotels. Sleep Inns are good too especially since they allowed a one time exception for pets in Concord, NC for the CCA nationals. I like MArriotts because a letter to HW about any problems gets a response.
Venetian is Vegas provided exceptional service and great rooms.
Complimentary breakfast are usually god awful.
Posted by: vaherder | July 27, 2007 10:33 AM
rvedx ayoqfxlts hjtaxvn tdxbwg dkpxr qkhjex moenxq
Posted by: cpxjvq ltnbve | August 15, 2007 1:25 AM
rvedx ayoqfxlts hjtaxvn tdxbwg dkpxr qkhjex moenxq
Posted by: cpxjvq ltnbve | August 15, 2007 1:26 AM
gfhrlp igqxzcjp mbnrt fovdslm nlkyqvm exwayr bfvr http://www.rxpcfwgbi.bgtciwl.com
Posted by: reshl lukyhvi | August 15, 2007 1:26 AM
I consult and spend a lot of time in hotels, last year about 200 nights. The one thing that I will not tolerate is a smoking room that has been "sprayed." I always put in the notes with the reservation that I require a "not smoked in and not sprayed room." If they can't provide that I go to another hotel. The spray, according to an MD neighbor, actually attacks the mucus membranes to kill the sense of smell. It also contains acetone which is a solvent for plastic so that it carries the smoke order into the plastics one has such as luggage, carpets, plastic bags etc. The acetone is also toxic to humans. If I have been in a "sprayed" room, I will have to air out the luggage and have all my clothes cleaned when home.
Posted by: jg robertson | August 30, 2007 9:51 AM
The comments to this entry are closed.











After getting screwed around by Marriott's event people earlier this year - basically lied to repeatedly, and charged for things they told me they wouldn't charge for - I do everything in my power never to stay there again.
On the other hand, the on-site staff at the hotel were nothing short of great. It's too bad that the "salespeople" were such sleazebags.